3.2 Leveraging the Core Competencies for Learner-Centered Assessment
Updated: Jul 31, 2023
The first time that fractions mattered to me was when I needed to calculate my overall percentage on a Math 12 exam. The mark was all that mattered, and I had ground myself to a nub using ineffective rehearsal strategies to try to prepare. I passed with an 86%, which met the threshold for an A! Success! Had I learned the material? Could I apply any skills later in university? No, I failed Calculus, and for the first time in my life, my confidence was truly shaken. Observations about my initial choice of major aside (I am a veteran English and History teacher and now live and breathe Literacy), my anecdote will be all too relatable to a great number of BC high school graduates this year.
I read an interesting article from Edutopia about how to avoid the “assessment trap” and help students get past number grades and into deep learning. It got me thinking about how the Core Competencies could be assessed and how to align that assessment with instruction in a student-centered classroom.
How to Help Students Focus on What They’re Learning, Not the Grade
Work that emphasizes students’ developing skills instead of a graded product reminds them to see learning as their goal.
Core Competencies for the Win!
Given the hubbub around the new K-12 Reporting Framework and the ensuing confusion about what constitutes assessment, I would like to highlight the Core Competencies as a means of guiding understanding. More to the point, I believe that teachers and parents would be more comfortable with reporting if they placed greater value on observation, conversation, and student self-assessment. The Core Competencies are woven into the curriculum across the subject areas, and lend themselves to assessment by observing, discussion, and student self-assessment.
Growth against the Core Competencies is measurable, but difficult to quantify, so in my experience, teachers may avoid composing their observations until report cards are upon them and they have gathered sufficient Gradebook evidence to assign a number grade. This is particularly evident in Competency Based IEP reports, where each student has at least one objective in a core competency, and often has several according to their unique learner profile. The Ministry of Education has released some supporting documents to clarify the use of the Proficiency Scales.
Developing self-reflective learners from K-12
Competencies are encountered through the curriculum. Here are some ways that K-12 teachers are encouraged to incorporate student self-assessment throughout a student’s career, culminating in the capstone project, which is a graduation requirement.
Student-centered curricular designs favour assessments that are aligned with instruction, so that the learning environment becomes a continuous feedback loop in which students are active participants. McMillan notes that “the right kind of assessment, and the manner in which it is integrated with instruction, can have dramatic effects on how much is learned and how well something is performed” (2014, p. 2). Recording this kind of data can be onerous if a teacher wants to capture copious notes on each student, or it can be very informal and part of the natural flow of a lesson or unit.
Here are 2 terrific resources:
A Simple Tool for Aligning Instruction and Assessment
This quick visual guide can help teachers ensure that their daily lessons align with their learning goals and assessments.
... and this article by Jay McTighe on Formative Assessment.
8 Quick Checks for Understanding
Formative assessment is a proven technique for improving student learning, and the strategies shared here by Jay McTighe work both in the classroom and remotely.
I would love to hear about the ways in which you have been successful with these forms of assessment and to extend this conversation to planning with Backward Design.
Websites to Visit (References)
BC Ministry of Education pages:
Articles in Edutopia:
Scholarly text:
McMillan, J. H. (2014). The Role of Assessment in Teaching. In J. H. McMillan, Classroom Assessment: principles and practice for effective standards-based instruction (6th edition.). (pp. 1-20). Pearson.
There is something appealing about discovering cultural connections through everyday stories, especially when the focus stays on the details people might otherwise overlook. An ordinary tradition can show how people remember and share a sense of place. I would connect Asianrichlist with cultural storytelling ideas through an ordinary example rather than a broad claim. I can imagine different responses depending on the situation, which makes the question more interesting. How would you invite different people to describe what the same tradition means to them?
A discussion of connecting food with farming and local production seems more useful when it connects an idea with something easy to picture. The work behind a familiar ingredient can be easy to overlook once it reaches a shop. For Ashclystfarmdairy, I would use local food production as a starting point for a closer discussion of the subject. The smaller details are what I would want to return to, especially when an explanation feels too broad. What part of the journey from producer to kitchen would you most like to understand?
I like thinking about exploring the details that shape a screen story through small observations rather than trying to reach a conclusion immediately. The order of two scenes can change what a viewer notices about a character. That thought gives me a starting point for exploring film storytelling ideas in connection with Aserbianfilm. It leaves me curious about the steps between understanding an idea and putting it into practice. Which small details make you want to revisit a scene after the story ends?
The idea of enjoying the small details of cafe culture gives me a reason to slow down and consider the details. The pace and atmosphere of a place can matter as much as what is in the cup. It is the kind of question I would keep in mind when thinking about Archibalds Coffee and cafe culture and coffee. I can imagine different responses depending on the situation, which makes the question more interesting. Which small details make you want to sit for a little longer?
I find finding the character of a local meeting place easier to approach when there is a familiar situation to start from. An ordinary conversation can become part of the reason people remember a place. That practical perspective helps me frame local pub culture as a theme for Abbeyinnderby. I would be interested in an example that shows how the idea works in an ordinary situation. What makes a local meeting spot feel welcoming to a first-time visitor?